American Idol Fan Site | Who got voted off American Idol

Last week the American Idol Girls dominated the week. The American Idol boys were a little tame, maybe nervous but definitely outclassed by their female counterparts. Will the boys live up to expectation tonight?

The guys of American Idol approached the stage for their first live performance Feb. 20, knowing all eyes were on them. It is up to America to decide now.

The final 12 men chosen by the judges last week each performed one song of their choice while judges Randy Jackson, Paula Abdul and Simon Cowell took the roles of back-seat drivers. After each performance, America called or text-messaged their votes.

So, how did the singers do for their first time?

“The first live performance by the top 12 guys was just OK,” said Rhonda Schaffer, 45, of Marlton. “Interestingly enough, not many stood out from the others.”

Maybe it was the pressure.

“It’s rough being the opening of the show and the season,” said Lorena Melcher, 45, of Somerdale, “but none of the first four singers were that exciting.”

Still, some seemed to make the best of the night and attracted the attention of the South Jersey American Idol devotees.

“Phil Stacey, whose wife just gave birth to their second daughter the day of his original audition, performed last and was tops,” said Schaffer. “He’ll go far in this competition based on that performance.”

Said Michelle Costello, 53, of Williamstown, “My favorites to go far in this competition are Chris Sligh and Blake Lewis. They have a great stage presence.”

However, the judges could only agree on one favorite.

“Only one singer got the satisfaction of getting the approval of all three judges and that was Blake Lewis,” said Tabitha Dupree, 28, of Lindenwold. “He got the title from Simon for being the best performance of the night.”

While most of the guys seemed to have failed in this round, a couple of contestants made an impression.

“Chris Richardson, whom the judges compared to Justin Timberlake, had a great song choice and performed it well,” said Schaffer.

Added Melcher, “Chris Sligh’s performance was pretty good, but I think he went overboard with his zing to Simon about Il Divo and Teletubbies. Simon is paid to be the nasty one. He’s usually right on with what he says and if he needs to revise his opinion he states it, as he did with AJ Tabaldo, when he said he might be better than he originally thought.”

The girls of American Idol may not have had a hard act to follow, but still gave their first live performance their best.

Garden State Idol fans are looking forward to see how far Antonella Barba of Point Pleasant will go as more contestants are voted off the show, and how she keeps her composure following the media buzz about risque photos of her that surfaced last week.

Meanwhile, the judges thought the girls posed as a threat to the guys. Some fans thought so, too.

“The girls were amazing,” said Schaffer. “I couldn’t believe the talent of these 12 women.”

Some shown brighter than others.

“Sabrina Sloan took command of the stage and showcased her talent,” said Melcher. “She showed America she wanted to win.”

Some voices were bigger than others.

“Melinda Doolittle was anything but little,” pointed out Schaffer. “Her voice was huge and her easiness on stage was probably from being a backup singer.”

And still others say the best was saved for last.

“Words cannot describe Lakisha Jones‘ performance,” said Schaffer.

“There was not one thing negative to say about her. Girls and guys alike should keep a very close eye on her.”

Then came judgment day and the votes were in. Four of the 24 American Idol contestants would not approach the stage again.

“The unfortunate contestants that were let go,” said Schaffer, “were ones that didn’t show the “wow’ factor that everyone looks for.”

Nicole Tranquillo, Paul Kim, Rudy Cardenas and Amy Krebs were voted off.

Tonight at 8pm EST the top 10 boys perform and the top 10 girls go on Wednesday at 8 Pm EST. The elimination round will be Thursday.

——–

Facebook Users Be sure to Like This POST

Follow us on Twitter @idolfans

American Idol News