American Idol Fan Site | Who got voted off American Idol

American Idol Conspiracy Theory Has Taylor Hicks Winning

Various conspiracy theories swirled around American Idol 4 that suggested the order of elimination might have been predetermined.  Some of the theories involved a rumored early press release listing the tracks on the American Idol Season 4 The Showstoppers CD in the exact order that the contestants were eventually eliminated.  The Independent, a British newspaper, also published that Carrie Underwood was the winner of American Idol 4 several days before the finale aired.  The newspaper removed the story but never offered an explanation for the error (that turned out to be accurate).

The first conspiracy theory for American Idol 5 has already surfaced.  A poster on the IdolForums.com message board identified as “Love4 CU JS n MG” made an interesting observation about the order the contestants were shown in during a recap on the Tuesday night American Idol performance show. 

Before the Top 12 Idols gave their performances, Ryan Seacrest announced “Your top 12, here they are” and a face shot of each Idol was quickly flashed on the screen.  The order the Idols were shown in were Melissa, Bucky, Lisa, Kevin, Ace, Kellie, Mandisa, Paris, Elliott, Katharine, Chris, and Taylor. 

“Love4 CU JS n MG” points back to the American Idol 4 finale and says the contestants were shown in their order of elimination with Bo Bice and then Carrie Underwood being the final two, which foreshadowed Carrie Underwood’s eventual win.  “Love4 CU JS n MG” suggests that this season’s recap could be foreshadowing the eventual order of elimination. 

So far only the Melissa elimination has come true, but the fact that Chris Daughtry and Taylor Hicks are the final two in this conspiracy theory does match up with what many are predicting.  Could Taylor Hicks be destined to defeat Chris Daughtry in the American Idol 5 Finale?

American Idol News

American Idol
American Idol News

Related posts:

1. Taylor Hicks Heart Full Of Soul
2. Taylor Hicks American Idol Winner MTV Exit interview
3. American Idol Taylor Hicks takes the Crown
4. Taylor Hicks is on top of the world
5. Judges Stops Producer of Old Taylor Hicks Songs